XCave.NET
Home · Reviews · FanFiction · Gallery · Blog · Contact Me

Reviews

Latest · DC · Image · Marvel · Indies · Non-Comic · Archives

52, Week 41

Reviewed by: Bruce Logan

Another week of 52 and let us see what does the magic crystal ball show us time around. Which character get shafted and crapped on, all to make way for yet another a ‘legacy’, one which as with just about everything DC lately is so shamelessly P.C. that that it doesn’t even border on the cliff it outright jumps into the abyss of ‘Easy-Breezy-No-Thinking-Involved’ ideas…well, if you can even call it an idea. Hmm, take an existing character, knock him off and put a ‘special interest’ character in his place.

Batgirl, Atom, Blue Beetle, Firestorm and more, all got, ahem, updated for the 21st century. I’d put Hawkman in there too, but in his case only the title underwent a change (to Hawkgirl), and that he is back…that is until he dies the next time around and returns again to die again. (Well, you get the idea.) Once a mainstay of fan fiction (or Elseworlds/AU stories), the different-sex different-race shtick has become the holy grail of the mainline DCU. So, it should not come as a surprise to any DC reader if a few months (or even weeks) from now, a new Question shows face (or in maybe does NOT show it). Yay for easy character assassinations, both figurative and literary.

Day 1: The journey through space continues as the now two, Adam Strange and Starfire, get attacked on and barely make it out alive, but not without Koriand’r getting severely wounded.

Day 2: And the Renee Montoya self-blame train takes off again, this time from Death Central station. For those wondering about her current state, don’t fret, after all seeing as she is to carry on a legacy, not only will Ms. Montoya miracously find her inner strength (to go with her spectacular martial art skills), she will also soon enough get the ‘conspiracy theorist’ attitude that her predecessor carried of so well.

Day 3: Don’t quite know what to make of this, other than having picked up the bottle (that Renee dropped off) the now perpetually drunk Ralph Dibny continues on his journey to try to get back his wife. Correct me, but wasn’t the whole purpose of Infinite Crisis to do away with all the Frank Miller-esque darkness blanketing the DCU? Oh sorry, I forgot that it was only for the Trinity, for Batman, Superman and…and…uh, that third one. Sorry but the name slips me right now. As for the Dibny plotline, even though it all seems to be building up to something worthwhile (and it better be), the whole journey thing has started to seem quite dragged out and monotonous.

Day 5: Back to Renee and with Drama Queen Montoya taking a back seat this day, Horndog (or will that be Hornb!tch?) Montoya sets a foot forward, only to get booted back. As for who this other woman is whom Renee meets, well, it could be anyone from Lady Shiva to (yet another earth version of) Vic Sage, one where he, uh, she is a woman. Then again, it could be Wonder Woman in her Post-IC but Pre-Hindenburg, I mean, Heinberg days, and the friend she is going to meet, well, I forgot the name of that oh-so-important Silver Age trinket-of-a-character’s name. Yeah, lets go with that one. That and her presence on the cover.

Day 7: Y’know, I really wish that instead of just forgetting about them (for weeks at a stretch), the writers of 52 would have done to the ‘space’ plot what they are doing now…that way, the emotional interactions (and its impact) between Starfire and Adam Strange would have been much more pronounced than coming off like ‘too little too late’. Still, anything that has a Mogo appearance gets double thumbs up from me.

Onto the ‘Origin’ and this time around it is Starfire.

The artwork of both the main story and the ‘origin’ backup works out quite well, albeit with a slightly over saturated coloring.

Conclusion: With just under a dozen weeks to go, here’s hoping that the story speed picks up. As for the Wonder Woman appearance (if I am correct about that), just seeing the duration of it should be an indication enough of her ‘real’ importance to the DCU (in the eyes of the writers if not DC’s TPTB).

RATING: 7.5/10

 

Reviews

More '52' Reviews

DISCLAIMER: This is a fan site and is NOT affiliated with any major company and/or comic publisher. It is also NOT in any way representative of the views of the owners (™ and ©) of the characters, their publications and/or their artwork.

Copyright 2005-2009 © XCave.NET

Home · Reviews · FanFiction · Gallery · Blog · Links · Contact Me · Site Map