XCave.NET

Got a 'Tagline' suggestion? Lemmie know!!

Home · Reviews · FanFiction · Gallery · Blog · Links · Contact Me

Reviews

Latest · DC · Image · Marvel · Indies · Non-Comic · Archives

The Evil Dead #2
Reviewed by: Bruce Logan

EXCLAMATION: “That’s some great artwork. Scary but great!!”

EXPLANATION: Taking up from where it last left this issue has its first half devoted to the (now) demonic Cheryl as she rampages against them. The group finally does get her contained but not before she stabs a pencil through Linda’s ankle. After a bit of a downtime its back to/with the demons as yet another amongst Ash & pals falls to the demonic side. This time around it is Shelly, yet another of Linda’s friends and the girlfriend of Ash’s friend Scotty. Freezing up again (as he did the first time around) Ash watches mutely as Scotty single handedly dispenses of the demonic threat (as he did the first time around), only this time it isn’t just limited to tossing the demon into the cellar but axing it/her up into little (almost a dozen) pieces.

EXAMINATION (Story): Officially Evil Dead the comic is billed as the comic book EXPANSION of the movie. What and how it is expanding upon and to is a mystery to me, someone who hasn’t seen any of the Evil Dead movies, including the one on which this comic is based upon. This also means that my views/take to this mini-series are solely based on its own strength and weaknesses and aren’t affected in any way of from memories of the movie.

Nevertheless, taken on itself Evil Dead (the mini) is an enjoyable read, both in the writing and in the art (more on that later). The only problem is that the concept somewhat shows its age. However, this is not due to its being set in the late 70s – early 80s but because given its cult success many a concept from this movie have been ‘adopted’ by many a movie to come after it, be they horror or parody or even ones from other genres. Had I watched the movie maybe my reaction would have been different but as it stands now it’s a case of “Didn’t I see this in XYZ movie?”

That said, thanks to a fairly fast paced if a bit shallow plot and the rather funny (esp. given the circumstances) inner monologue of Ashe’s Evil Dead both reaches up and goes above my wall of jaded cynicism.

EXAMINATION (Art): Ash continues to be blurred (albeit a bit less than last issue); the rest of the artwork continues to be great (a bit more if that’s possible) and John Bolton’s artwork continues to make a fan out of me. Granted it’s only in the horror genre (‘m not sure about seeing the same style in, say, the superhero genre) but for a horror story such as this, especially one based on/around a movie, Bolton’s photorealism is a definite plus.

PROCLAMATION: As thoughts as last time around – both writing and art are solid, yet the struggle is to breathe life into a more than quarter century old storyline.

RATING: 4/5

 

Reviews

DISCLAIMER: This is a fan site and is NOT affiliated with any major company. It is also NOT in any way representative of the views of the owners (™ and ©) of the characters, their publications and/or their artwork.

Copyright 2005-2008 © XCave.NET

Home · Reviews · FanFiction · Gallery · My Blog · Contact Me · Site Map